Thursday, January 11, 2007

Fiction Equals Truth?

As Kaye mentioned yesterday, it's not often easy to take yourself out of a mindset you've had your entire life. That's a necessity as an author. I'm sure you've read books where your perspective was broadened by a character or viewpoint the author included through thorough research in the story. On the flip side, you've no doubt read something where the viewpoints were limited and obviously centrally-focused from the author's perspective.

Sure, it's easy to take your own viewpoints and carry them into your writing, but it's much more of a challenge to put yourself in the shoes of someone else. Get into their head, their skin, and see how it fits for a little while. Lay aside everything that's formed your own sphere of influence and "live" life as that other person. This applies to writing as much as it does in relationships with other folks. But that's a topic for another blog. :)

I've discovered the challenge this presents researching for my Colonial era series. Not only do I have loyal patriots to the American cause for independence, but because of the setting, I also have Dutch, Swedish and British characters. Each one comes from a different background, with a different set of beliefs and motivations for their actions. When I wrote the first draft of book 1 and sent it off to be critiqued/edited, notes came back that several characters fell "flat" with stereotypical characterizations and shallow motivations.

So, back to the research resources I went. When I was able to dig deeper into the character backgrounds, I was able to present the motivations from a perspective that was true to that character. Who they are and why they reacted the way they did directly correlated with each other. It started making sense and provided a richer more complex character.

I'm in the middle of book 2 at the moment, and a large portion of story focuses on the French & Indian War where the patriots/Americans are fighting on the side of the French and against the British. However, the hero of the book is British and the heroine is from a family that is leaning more and more toward the American way of thinking every day.

The emotions during this time were quite volatile. Britain was causing unrest amongst the American colonists due to what colonists termed "unfair taxes"; many colonists began seeking a better way of life separate from British rule; Britain tried maintaining a hold on their colonies while fighting against the French for greater control of this "new world" land; the natives in America couldn't decide on which side they wanted to fight and who they wanted to support because both sides were considered an "invasion" to them. While all of this was taking place, the governmental associations within each colony were beginning to come together and would soon lead to the forming of the 1st Continental Congress.

That's a lot of perspectives and a lot of internal motivations that lead to physical motivations and misunderstandings. It would be easy to focus on just one viewpoint and make that the guiding factor in the books. But, to accurately portray the realities of the times, so much more is required.

So, now it's your turn. Share some books where you feel the author successfully accomplished this and/or why the book compelled you to keep reading. On the flip side, share some books where you didn't get into the story and why. Tomorrow, Kaye will be back to share some of her research strategies and resources, and I'll return on Saturday to close out the week with some of mine.

See you again soon!

9 comments:

Cindy Thomson said...

Oops! I shared one yesterday. Why did it keep me reading? I think because I felt it was fair. I read one of Bernard Cornwell's book's once, The Last Kingdom. I really enjoyed the book, it was well done, but noted a lack of women characters. The women were there, but mostly ignored (except for you know what.) Surely women in this time and place had some kind of impact and I would have preferred to read some of the story from their perspective. (Gee, I hope I haven't mixed this up with another book. I'm packing up the entire house and can't reference my copy!)

Anonymous said...

As I'm sure is obvious by now, I admire these aspects in Diana Gabaldon's OUTLANDER novels, particularly the latter ones set in the American colonies, on the eve of the Revolution (beginning with DRUMS OF AUTUMN). She portrays slave characters as more than victims, powerful and affective within their limitations. She portrays Cherokee and Iroquois characters as true to their culture and the influence of the times, as they relate to the white cultures "invading their space". There is the usual hodgepodge of backcountry colonial settlers and European immigrants. And then there are the 18th century Scots. *s*

What helps to contrast these historical attitudes and perspectives is that several of her main characters are time travelers from the 20th century. We most often see the 18th century through their eyes, but we also get to see _them_ through 18th century eyes. Diana does both of these honestly, and her research is thorough.

Plus, she's a generous lady who has done much over the years toward helping me see the need (and the work it takes) to get under the skin of a man or woman of an earlier time period and see through their eyes. In other words, to write something more than a costume drama.

Lori

Anonymous said...

Oops. That last post was mine. Forgot to add my name.

Tiffany Amber Stockton said...

Lori, you're absolutely right. Diana Gabaldon is a fantastic author. It's no wonder her books are NYTimes Bestsellers. I could do without certain scenes (grins) but the depiction of characters is excellent and true to the time period. Compelling and sympathetic to each character's individual plight.

So has Diana helped you personally or just inspired you through her own writing?

And Cindy, it happens sometimes with male authors who downplay the role of women...especially when writing historicals. They focus too much on the things that appeal to men and leave out how important women were even if they were in the background. Sad, really.

Cindy Thomson said...

Hey, Lori (and everyone), I just thought I'd mention that Diana Gabaldon will be at the Historical Novel Society Conference this June.
Conference Web site

Anonymous said...

Tiff,

I know Diana through Compuserve's Books and Writers Forum. She is one of the section leaders for the Research & Craft folder. Her posts, to me and to others, are always informative, whether it's a craft issue or a research question posed. This is a group of published and unpublished writers seriously dedicated to improving their craft and making progress on their WIPs. I recommend the place. It's not a Christian forum; there are writers there from very walk of life (including Christians), from many different countries (lots from Germany), but it's very professional, welcoming and encouraging. And very, very active.

Anonymous said...

Cindy,

The link to the Historical Novels conference didn't work for me, but I'm interested in checking it out. Diana does the Surrey, BC conference every fall, but it's more than I can afford, with the travel involved and all.

Cindy Thomson said...

Lori,
Sorry. Try this http://snipurl.com/17dlh

If that doesn't work, search for Historical Novel Society Conference. It's in Albany, NY

Tiffany Amber Stockton said...

HNS...gee, yet another dues-driven organization that would be great to join IF novelists made more money. :)

Would LOVE to meet Diana one day though. Thanks for the forum info. Might check it out.